3

Why is "tren" singular in "estación de tren", but "autobuses" is plural in "estación de autobuses" (per the website Duolingo)?

Or is it also correct if I write "estación de trenes" or "estación de autobús"?

3 Answers 3

1

I don't know about Duolingo but according to the DRAE:

estación

  1. f. Edificio o edificios en que están las oficinas y dependencias de una estación del ferrocarril o de autobús.

Notice that the DRAE employs the singular form in the above definition (just replace ferrocarril by train, they are synonymous)

You can use both singular and plural forms to designate the same building. A estación de tren is the same as a estación de trenes. And the same occurs with autobus/autobuses.

As pointed by other users, in small populations train stations usually has got a single line, just one train comes around, and due to Spain being a rural country for a long time that name remains.

As a side note, in great cities, the central train station (with multiple lines) is usually know by its proper name, like Atocha in Madrid or María Zambrano in Málaga, while bus stations have got not proper name or nobody uses it.

1

Both "estación de trenes" and "estación de autobús" are correct, it's just that "estación de tren" and "estación de autobuses" are more common than the alternatives (at least in Spain).

As for why, my wild guess is that no more than one train is usually stopped in smaller "estaciones de tren" at a given time, but even the smallest "estaciones de autobuses" frequently see multiple buses stopping at the same time (otherwise they would be mere bus stops). Again, this is just a wild guess.

2
  • I think that this comment should be included in the post even if it's a wild guess. Comments may be deleted due to multiple casuistics.
    – RubioRic
    Commented May 7, 2020 at 12:13
  • Done. I'm not very comfortable doing that, though. Commented May 7, 2020 at 13:23
0

No sé si puedo responder en español para ser más claro. Mi suposición es la siguente. En cada "estación de autobuses" paran varias líneas mientras que en una "estación de tren" a lo mucho pasan 2 trenes que vayan a distintos lugares.

Sin embargo, en Argentina, es mucho más frecuente usar "parada" (creo que uds. también usan la palabra "stop") acompañado de "colectivo/bondi/ómnibus/autobús" en singular. Así que no parece tener ninguna relación.

1
  • En realidad, es muy habitual que haya más de 2 vias por estación. Tampoco es raro encontrar estaciones en sentido unico (e.g. Lucerna Suiza, con 14 vías). También hay que diferenciar vía (rail), andén (donde esperas al lado de la vía), y parada (una de las estaciones donde para un tren a lo largo de su trayecto). Commented Aug 12, 2021 at 11:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.