3

In English "to come" is used loosely. In Spanish it's different, it can only be used when the person speaking invites or asks the other person to go to the place where the 1st person at. Right?

If I'm the 2nd person, what should I use instead of "to come" then? Examples in English:

1) If I come to your house after 5 pm, will you still be there?

2) I came here yesteday and it was a lot of fun.

3) When should I come?

6

You have two verbs, ir and venir, corresponding loosely to "to go" and "to come". The key is where the movement starts and ends (or its goal) and where you are right now. Your first example should use ir:

  1. Si voy a tu casa después de las 5, ¿estarás todavía ahí?

This is because you're not in the hearer's house right now, so you need to go there.

In the second example you should use venir:

  1. Vine aquí ayer y fue muy divertido.

This is because you're already in the place you're referring to (that's why you said "here" and not "there"), and you're describing your movement from somewhere else to this place. From this point of view you didn't go; you instead came.

The third example could use either ir or venir depending on context, but for the most part you would use ir:

  1. ¿Cuándo debería ir?

This is because "When should I come?" is not a question you'd normally ask if you were already in the place you're asking about; if that were the case, you'd rather ask "When should I come back here?" or "When should I come here next time?". If this "next time" has already been established by context, though, the question does make sense:

  1. ¿Cuándo debería venir?
  • 3) --> Why debería? Why not debo? – nylypej Oct 20 '18 at 2:49
  • debo is (more or less) "shall", debería is "should". – ths Oct 20 '18 at 11:35
  • Yes, as @ths says, Cuándo debo...? would be between "When shall I...?" and "When must I...?". Debería suggests recommendation or advice, debo suggests obligation and can be too forceful. – pablodf76 Oct 20 '18 at 14:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.