6

Both verbs tener and haber both are translated as to have.

What are the rules that distinguish the use of one verb over the other?

4

Haber meaning to be in possession of is not really used anymore. However, haber meaning to be obliged to is equivalent to tener:

Juan tiene que ir al médico.

Juan ha de ir al médico.

Although I would say that the second sentence is more formal.

Other than that, haber is mainly used to conjugate other verbs, or meaning to exist as explained in this article by the RAE.

| improve this answer | |
4

You can translate "tener" as to have but I think translating "haber" the same way is far from being the best option. "Haber" has quite a few usages and "to have" is the least common (the RAE list it as obsolete http://buscon.rae.es/drae/srv/search?id=5ra5cGATFDXX2hZam4lB)

The main uses of "haber" are as an auxiliary verb for compound verbal constructions and the other is to indicate existence in impersonal sentences (without subject).

  • The first usage may be translated as "have" but only auxiliary cases like "See what you have done" "I have had my breakfast", etc.
  • The second usage can be translated as "there + to be": There are three dogs in that house --> "Hay tres perros en esa casa"
| improve this answer | |
2

Tener

To have something. To possess something, a feeling, etc.

Tengo dos gatos

Tengo tres dólares en mi mano

Tenemos miedo de tí

Él tiene frío

Haber

  • To have existence.
  • To be obliged to do something.
  • To have had done something.

Hay dos camas en el cuarto

Ya lo he visto

Hay que hacer ejercicios.

It is mainly used in its auxiliary form to create a "perfect" tense.

Ya comí / I already ate

vs

Ya he comido / I have already eaten

| improve this answer | |
0

"Haber" and "tener" have very different meanings and can almost never be used interchangeably. Haber can mean there is/are or can be used to form the perfect tense.

e.g: Hay muchas personas aquí = There are many people here. (haber in the sense of 'there is'. Ya has comido? = have you eaten? (haber in the perfect tense)

Tener generally means to have but can also be often translated as 'to be' in certain expressions.

e.g:tengo dos perros=I have two dogs. tienes un cigarrillo?=Do you have a cigarette?

tengo hambre=I am hungry. Él tiene seis años=He is six years old

In short, if you are wanting to say 'to have' in the traditional sense of the verb, use 'tener'. If you want to say 'to have' to express the perfect tense, use 'haber'.

This blog post goes into more detail: Haber vs tener: https://www.clozemaster.com/blog/spanish-haber-vs-tener/

Clozemaster is a language learning game. Its blog has a lot of useful posts on Spanish grammar. Hope this could be of help.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    If the link goes dead this is not going to be very helpful. Could you edit your answer to include more detail from the blog you link to? – mdewey Jul 12 '18 at 10:51
  • Hi there, I have edited my answer to include more information and gave some more info about the blog as well. Hope that is sufficient. – polyglottera Jul 12 '18 at 22:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.