Take the 2-minute tour ×
Spanish Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Spanish language. It's 100% free, no registration required.

The sentence I want to translate is:

The wine cellar should be dark and dry.

Which of the following would be more appropriate and why?

La bodega debe ser oscura y seca.

La bodega debe estar oscura y seca.

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

up vote 2 down vote accepted

In my opinion, it should be the first one, but actually, it could be both depending on the case.

I guess that wine cellars, in general, have to be dark and dry. So if you are talking about a general case it should be the first one. Let's put it this way:

All wine cellars should be dark and dry.

Las bodegas deberían ser oscuras y secas.

In the other hand, if this was not the case, and if you were talking about a specific moment for the wine cellar (which in this case I do not think it would be often) it should be the seconde one. Let's change the example:

My house should be clean for this weekend.

Mi casa debería estar limpia para este fin de semana.

This is because you are talking about a specific moment (in time) of the house. It is not how houses are supposed to be, it is how they are in a certain period of time. If we change the example a bit again:

My house has to be bright and white.

Mi casa tiene que ser luminosa y blanca.

It is a state, not a specific moment.

P.S.: Note the gender of the adjectives in the examples, bodega is femenine.

EDIT

I have to say that, thinking deeply about this, this is what you will find most (like 90%) of times (for any example, not just this one). It is true that some people may use the second sentence as a translation for your question. I think that they would mean that wine cellars have to be dark and dry as a moment in time, if you want to have good wine. But as I said, it should be the first one :)

share|improve this answer
1  
Thanks for the exhaustive answer. And thanks also for pointing out the mistake in gender which I have now corrected. Just had one question though: Any particular reason to prefer “debería” over “debe” in that example? –  Amit Schandillia Apr 4 at 10:45
1  
I just answered your other question, which is related to the debería and deber question. Check it and if you still do not understand, just ask ;) –  makeMonday Apr 4 at 10:50

Think of "ser" as a inherent property of the subject, and "estar" as a temporal property.

So if somebody "is handsome" can be "es guapo" or "está guapo", the first meaning he is a handsome person always and the second one that he looks handsome at that moment.

share|improve this answer

The other answers point out an ambiguity in your original sentence: when should the cellar be dark and dry?

I'd rephrase the original question as

The wine cellar should always be dark and dry.

That translates cleanly to

La bodega siempre debe estar oscura y seca.

and I think it's a sentence you're more likely to actually hear when talking about wine cellars. Otherwise, if the original sentence belongs to a longer paragraph, I'd want to read the context to know how to better translate. Perhaps the text gives a general sense of the time. E.g., in instructions for building or cleaning a wine cellar, the "always" is implied. Finally, though it might be fine to say

La bodega debe ser seca

it's not a sentence that I'd ever write, because "dryness" is not an inherent quality of a cellar, but something that you have to make an effort to obtain.

share|improve this answer

That's a good occasion to use the verb "permanecer". Otherwise, in spanish, "ser" is used as a way to describe the long-run state, while "estar" is used for short-run, varying properties. Similarly we use "estar" when we describe what we now do ("estoy pensando"), while we use "ser" for inherent properties and actions of the subject.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.