Take the 2-minute tour ×
Spanish Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Spanish language. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What is the difference in using those tempos in reported speech apart from representing the future in the past?

  1. Dijo que compraba el perro
  2. Dijo que compraría el perro
share|improve this question
    
I guess you wanted to write perro instead of pero :) –  Gorpik Feb 5 at 10:01
add comment

3 Answers

up vote 2 down vote accepted

In spanish the first tends to be used when the speaker you are reffering is decided to do it, while the second one is conditioned and he/she won't do it due to something.

Maybe with the verb comprar in this example we cannot apply the general rule from Presente to Pretérito Imperfecto del indicativo except if we specify when because the verb itself only takes place for a short time.

But for a recurrent action we can say:

John te dice:

  • Canto/Compro muy bien (I sing so well)

Un día despues le dices a Maria:

  • (John) Dijo que cantaba/compraba muy bien (He said that He was good at singing/buying)

The second option can match with the conditionals:

John te dice:

  • Compraría el coche, pero no tengo dinero or Compraría el coche si tuviera dinero (I would buy the car but.../if I...)

Un día despues le dices a Maria:

  • (John) Dijo que compraría el coche , pero no tenía dinero or (John) Dijo que compraría el coche si tuviera dinero (He said he would buy the car but.../if he...)

I was trying to make a better answer with more examples but the differences between English and Spanish about these report speech (estilos indirectos) and uses of present/past are a bit different.

share|improve this answer
    
I used just a random verb. I've taken a note in a book that in addition to complex conditional sentence completed with "si tuviera" it was used as is from my example without it –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:57
add comment

First things first: By "pero" you mean "perro" , am i right?. :-)

1) Means he was doing that while talking. Sound to me like: Dijo que estaba comprando... (He/she said he was buying the dog). At the same moment of talking.

2) Means that he/she would buy the dog in the future from the moment of the conversation, but... we still don't know if he really did it. It means like a "promise".

Anyway, the first sentence is a little weird.

share|improve this answer
    
both sentences are from the reported speech in correct usage –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:58
    
I agree, the first sentence is odd because it translates to "He said he was buying the dog"... indicating that something else occurred during the action. "He said he was buying the dog when....something happened." Él dijo que compró el perro is very definitive and the timeline is terminated.. the has been bought. –  dockeryz Feb 5 at 18:00
add comment

The difference is quite subtle. In the first case, you are pretty confident that the person will do as she said, while in the second case you are not so confident. The conditional always expresses a possibility and not a certainty.

  1. María dijo que compraba el perro --> María said that she was buying the dog and you have no reason to believe that she did not do as she said.
  2. María dijo que compraría el perro --> María said that she was buying the dog but, for whatever reason, you thing that she might not have done so.
share|improve this answer
    
I see the difference is related to the future tenses in English. will: possibility; going to: planned action; is taking: definite process –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:51
    
I will buy the dog –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:51
    
I'm going to buy the dog –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:51
    
I'm buying the dog –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:53
    
I will be buying the dog –  Chesnokov Yuriy Feb 5 at 13:53
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.